Skip to content
  • Home
  • News
  • Contact
Steven T. Peluso, Esq.Steven T. Peluso, Esq.
Steven T. Peluso, Esq.Steven T. Peluso, Esq.
  • Home
  • News
  • Contact

US Supreme Court Issues Decision in the Google vs Oracle Application Programming Interface (API) Case

Home Court DecisionsUS Supreme Court Issues Decision in the Google vs Oracle Application Programming Interface (API) Case

US Supreme Court Issues Decision in the Google vs Oracle Application Programming Interface (API) Case

April 12, 2021 Court Decisions, Intellectual Property, Technology

On April 5th, the US Supreme Court decided Google LLC v. Oracle America, Inc. 593 U.S. ___ (2021).  This widely watched case involved Application Programming Interface (API) software that is part of Sun Java SE. The software is owned by Oracle.  Google copied parts of the API for use in its Android operating platform and in doing so Oracle alleged violated Oracle’s copyright.  Two questions were before the Court: (i) could Oracle copyright the lines of API code that Google had copied; and (ii) was Google’s copying of the code permissible as “fair use.”

Google argued that the API could not be copyrighted as it was excluded from copyright under 17 U.S. Code § 102 (b) which provides: “In no case does copyright protection for an original work of authorship extend to any idea, procedure, process, system, method of operation, concept, principle, or discovery, regardless of the form in which it is described, explained, illustrated, or embodied in such work.”  In the alternative, Google argued that even if the API were copyrightable its use was permissible under the “fair use” doctrine.  The Court declined to decide on the issue of copyright-ability of the API electing to “assume, for argument’s sake, that the material was copyrightable.”

17 U.S. Code § 107 sets forth a four-part test to determine fair use.  The factors to be considered shall include:

  1. the purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes;
  2. the nature of the copyrighted work;
  3. the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; and
  4. the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.

The Court made it clear that fair use is a flexible concept the application of which may vary depending on the context.  The Court also clarified that fair use can present mixed questions of both law and fact and that “a reviewing Court should try to break such a question into its separate factual and legal parts, reviewing each according to the appropriate legal standard.”  The Court held that “[i]n this case, the ultimate “fair use” question primarily involves legal work.”

In applying the fair use test the Court held:

  1. That even though the use was commercial in nature it was “transformative” and added something new with a further purpose or different character thereby altering the copyrighted work with a new expression, meaning or message.
  2. In analyzing the nature of the copyrighted work, the Court found that the API had three (3) parts:  implementing code, method calls and declaring code.  The API at issue in the case involved only declaring code.  The Court found that declaring code is “further than are most computer programs (such as the implementing code) from the core of copyright” and called into question if declaring code is copyrightable at all.  In coming to its conclusion, the Court stated “[b]ut unlike many other programs, its [declaring code] use is inherently bound together with uncopyrightable ideas (general task division and organization) and new creative expression (Android’s implementing code).”
  3. Although Google copied the entirety of the API declaring code this accounted for only a small portion of the total API code. The Court based its calculation of percent of use on the total number of lines of code in the software and not a subset thereof and found only approximately .4% of the total lines of API code were copied.
  4. With respect to market effect, the Court held that “[t]he uncertain nature of Sun’s [Oracle’s predecessor] ability to compete in Android’s market place, the sources of its lost revenue, and the risk of creativity-related harms to the public, when taken together, convince that this fourth factor—market effects—also weighs in favor of fair use.”

A copy of the Court’s opinion can be found here: https://spelusolawoffice.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/18-956_new_o7jp.pdf.

You also might be interested in

Corporate Transparency Act Update

Mar 26, 2024

In an earlier post, we reported on the Corporate Transparency[...]

European Commission Issues Updated GDPR Standard Contractual Clauses

Oct 17, 2021

In accordance with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), contractual[...]

Citibank’s Costly Mistake

Feb 21, 2021

In 2016, Revlon, Inc. entered into a syndicated term loan[...]

Latest Posts

  • Artificial Intelligence, Tertiary Education and the Workforce: More Than Meets the Eye?
  • A Proposed Federal Regulatory Framework for Artificial Intelligence: CFIUS for AI
  • Pell Grants Extended to Vocational Training Programs
  • University of California Faculty Call for Reinstatement of SAT, ACT Math Scores for Undergraduate STEM Applicants
  • In a Response to Grade Inflation Harvard Caps the Number of A’s Awared at its Undergraduate College
  • UC Berkeley Releases Paper on AI’s Impact on Grade Inflation
  • Princeton To Require Proctoring for All In-Person Examinations in Response to AI Cheating

Categories

  • Accreditation
  • Affiliates
  • Apprenticeships
  • Certification
  • Court Decisions
  • Data Privacy
  • Education
  • Employment
  • European Union
  • Human Resources
  • Intellectual Property
  • Licensure
  • News
  • Regulation
  • Security and Intelligence
  • Technology

Contact Us

Send us an email and we'll get back to you.

Please reach out. We look forward to hearing from you. Contact

Contact Us

Steven T. Peluso, JD, MBA
The St. James Building
1133 Broadway, Suite 304
New York, New York
Phone: 917.270.9083
Email: info@spelusolawoffice.com

ATTORNEY ADVERTISING

This website and its related contents are attorney advertising.

NO ATTORNEY-CLIENT RELATIONSHIP

This website is not meant to be, nor should it be construed to be, rendering legal advice or service.  Viewing this website does not establish an attorney-client relationship and any such relationship is explicitly disclaimed by the firm.

DISCLAIMER

This website, its contents, news articles and any links or references therein are provided strictly for informational purposes and is not legal advice. The firm makes no representations or warranties as to their accuracy. The viewer accepts and accesses this website “as is” and agrees to hold the firm harmless from any liability, loss or damage of any kind incurred as a result of use.  By viewing this website the viewer agrees to be bound by this disclaimer.

© 2012 - 2026 Steven T. Peluso, Esq. All rights reserved.

Prev Next

Press Enter to search · Esc to close